Select Page

In the realm of employment, the term “at-will” often surfaces, leading to questions about job security and the rights of employees. “At-will” employment means that an employer can terminate an employee at any time for nearly any reason—or for no reason at all. Conversely, employees can also leave their jobs whenever they wish without facing penalties. However, this seemingly straightforward concept comes with important exceptions that every worker should know. Let’s delve into these exceptions to better understand the protections available to “at-will” employees.

Legal Exceptions to “At-Will” Employment

Though “at-will” employment suggests broad freedoms for employers to terminate employment, there are critical legal exceptions designed to protect workers from unfair dismissal. Below, we explore these exceptions and provide examples to illustrate how they apply in real-world scenarios.

1. Discrimination

Under most circumstances, Arizona law—and indeed laws across many jurisdictions—prohibits employers from firing individuals based on discriminatory reasons. Discrimination can be based on:

  • Race
  • Color
  • Religion
  • Sex
  • Pregnancy
  • Sexual orientation
  • National origin
  • Age (typically for individuals 40 and older)
  • Disability
  • Medical or genetic conditions

For example, if an employer fires an employee simply because of their religion or sexual orientation, this action likely constitutes unlawful discrimination. It’s important to note that there are rare exceptions, so consulting with an employment lawyer is crucial to understand your specific situation.

2. Retaliation

Retaliation occurs when an employer dismisses an employee as a punishment for engaging in legally protected activities. In Arizona, it’s illegal for an employer to terminate employment because an employee has complained about discrimination—either regarding themselves or others.

Imagine an employee reports racial discrimination they’ve witnessed in the workplace. If they are fired for making this report, they may have a case for retaliation against their employer.

3. Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA) Violations

The FMLA allows eligible employees to take unpaid, job-protected leave for specified family and medical reasons. It is illegal for an employer to fire someone for requesting or taking FMLA leave. For instance, if an employee is terminated for taking time off to care for a sick family member under FMLA, this would likely be considered an unlawful dismissal.

4. Contractual Agreements

Not all employment relationships are “at-will.” Some employees have contracts that outline the terms of employment, including reasons for termination. If you have a written, verbal, or implied contract (such as promises made in an employee handbook), and you’re fired in violation of those terms, you might have a case against your employer. For example, if your employer promised job security in an employee handbook but fired you without cause, this might breach your implied contract.

5. Labor Union Protections

If you’re a member of a labor union, your employment might be governed by a collective bargaining agreement that provides additional protections against unfair dismissal. Union contracts often stipulate specific procedures that must be followed before an employee can be terminated.

Seeking Legal Guidance

Employers may not always disclose the true reason behind a termination. If you suspect that your dismissal was due to discrimination, retaliation, FMLA violations, contract breaches, or union protections, it’s essential to seek legal advice. An employment lawyer can help you navigate your rights and determine whether you have a valid claim against your employer.

Remember, understanding your rights is the first step towards protecting your employment and ensuring fair treatment in the workplace. If you believe you’ve been unjustly fired, don’t hesitate to reach out for legal assistance to explore your options.

J. Horowitz
J. Horowitz

J. Horowitz leverages over two decades of experience as a seasoned employment law attorney in Arizona to offer insightful freelance writing on the same subject. After a successful career advocating for fairness and justice in the workplace, J. now dedicates his expertise to writing comprehensive articles, blog posts, and thought leadership pieces that illuminate the complexities of employment law.