Select Page

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is a pivotal piece of civil rights legislation enacted in 1990, designed to protect individuals with disabilities from discrimination in various sectors including employment. This law ensures that qualified individuals with disabilities receive equal opportunities in job hiring, promotions, and when decisions are made about their employment termination. Furthermore, it mandates that employers make reasonable accommodations for the physical or mental limitations of these individuals unless doing so causes undue hardship to the business.

Defining Reasonable Accommodations

A reasonable accommodation is an adjustment or modification provided by an employer to enable people with disabilities to have equal employment opportunities. These accommodations can include making physical changes to the workplace, providing specialized equipment, adjusting work schedules, or modifying job duties. For instance, an employer might install a wheelchair ramp, provide a sign language interpreter, or allow a flexible work schedule.

Examples of Reasonable Accommodations:

  • Physical adjustments: Installing ramps, modifying restrooms, or ensuring wheelchair accessibility.
  • Equipment provision: Offering screen reader software for visually impaired employees or ergonomic furniture for those with back issues.
  • Schedule and duties modification: Allowing telecommuting, part-time hours, or reassigning non-essential job tasks.

The Limitation of Undue Hardship

While the ADA promotes accessibility and inclusion, it recognizes that not all accommodations are feasible. An accommodation is considered an “undue hardship” if it would result in significant difficulty or expense relative to the size, resources, and nature of the business. Lawmakers intended to balance the needs of individuals with disabilities against the practical capabilities of businesses, acknowledging that some accommodations might be prohibitively costly or disruptive.

Example of Undue Hardship:

A small business may not be able to afford the cost of remodeling its entire facility to accommodate one employee, especially if such modifications would jeopardize the financial stability of the business.

The Grey Area of Reasonable Accommodation

Despite the ADA’s guidelines, the concept of what is “reasonable” can be subjective and often leads to disputes between employers and employees. The law does not have a definitive list of required accommodations, and what is reasonable in one context may not be in another. This ambiguity often results in legal challenges.

Controversial Cases:

  • An employee with minor back pain requesting a high-end ergonomic setup might be debatable, depending on the nature of their job and the employer’s resources.
  • A visually impaired employee might reasonably request software modifications, but asking for extensive changes to all company systems might pose an undue hardship.

Understanding Disability Definitions

Another complex aspect of the ADA is determining what constitutes a disability. Obvious disabilities include conditions like paralysis or blindness. However, less apparent conditions, such as chronic back pain or severe nearsightedness, also qualify. The determination often depends on how the disability affects the individual’s daily life and ability to perform job functions.

Examples of Disabilities:

  • Obvious disabilities: Conditions like quadriplegia, blindness, or deafness.
  • Less visible disabilities: Chronic illnesses, mental health disorders, or learning disabilities that significantly impact daily activities.

Conclusion and Seeking Legal Advice

Navigating the intricacies of the ADA, particularly regarding what constitutes a reasonable accommodation and defining disability, can be challenging. Employees who encounter issues with obtaining reasonable accommodations are advised to consult with an employment discrimination attorney. Legal professionals specializing in this field can provide guidance and representation to ensure that the rights of individuals with disabilities are upheld.

For individuals in Arizona facing such issues, seeking advice from a local attorney experienced in employment discrimination law is crucial. They can help clarify rights under the ADA and assist in negotiating with employers to find a fair and legal resolution to accommodation requests.

J. Horowitz
J. Horowitz

J. Horowitz leverages over two decades of experience as a seasoned employment law attorney in Arizona to offer insightful freelance writing on the same subject. After a successful career advocating for fairness and justice in the workplace, J. now dedicates his expertise to writing comprehensive articles, blog posts, and thought leadership pieces that illuminate the complexities of employment law.